|

Figure 1: The exemplar apron anchors the ramp with its L-shaped
edge straddling the beam in the trailer floor. The two carriage bolts,
on the other side of the I-beam provide added security from slippage.

Figure 2: The exemplar ramp as it is anchored to the I-beam of the
floor of the trailer

Figure 3: A view of the incident walk ramp and apron. The apron was
welded by an inexperienced welder. It broke causing bodily injury
to our client.

Figure 4: A close-up of the incident apron showing discoloration at the
fracture face and bright face of the last metal to fracture.
The discoloration indicates that the failure
occurred gradually. Note that the bolts holding the hooks are inserted
into holes not in the original sheet metal perforations. An extra hole
is seen between the two holes that hold the support bolts. |